Strengthening the newest take to
Our try is founded on fifty groups of well-known memes, many of which incorporated an introducing meme such as and you may 20 various other items (including, the initial “Charlie Piece My https://datingranking.net/hindu-dating/ personal Finger” films and you will 20 imitations/remixes from the video). Ideally, a complete test perform had been 1050 meme instances (fifty family members X 21 hours), but not, since the particular meme parents did not have an introducing meme including (elizabeth.g. „Facepalm,” „Lolcats”), all of our latest decide to try consisted of 1013 units getting research. Distinguishing the most common meme group is perhaps an impossible activity as a result of the dynamic nature out-of memes together with various methods for comparing their dominance (check counts, likes/votes, amount of derivations, number of mentions browsing abilities, and so on); yet not, i suggest here a structured processes to understand very popular meme family predicated on a variety of academic and you will net-dependent source.
First, by using the fresh new KnowYourMeme database (pick along with Phillips, 2012 ; Shifman, 2013 a great, 2013 b), i developed a listing of 1168 accepted meme household. In order to filter this new 50 most well known ones, i triangulated lists of popular memes looking in the informative paperwork (Bauckhage, 2011 ; Knobel & Lankshear, 2007 ; Shifman, 2012 , 2013 b) with their search engines like google popularity. and you will Bing (into legitimacy and precision of the strategy see and additionally ).
When a good meme had several you are able to titles, for example “Charlie Section Me personally” and you will “Charlie Section My personal Little finger – Again!,” we sought out the identity you to definitely produced the highest amount of google search results while having appeared in the greatest level of educational sources. I ranked the brand new meme family members predicated on the website popularity additionally the quantity of educational supply one to recognized him or her. Outside of the 50 meme group, 40 was in fact chosen using this method. Eventually, because the informative present listed just memes until 2010, to is more recent memes, i extra 10 extra prominent memes after the an equivalent procedure, but instead of triangulating the information with educational sources.
We put a mixture of one or two common meme-mainly based social network other sites (Reddit and you can Tumblr), to to locate 20 other cases of each of the 50 meme family members. I made use of the headings of your own 50 selected memes (age.g., “Charlie Section Me personally”) given that browse issues within these social networking sites. In place of medium-particular se’s for example YouTube, this process enabled us to pick a variety of popular films, pictures, and you will text types of your own meme group. These sites also let sorting according to their internal ranks assistance: To own reddit, we utilized the vote get, figuring the essential difference between self-confident (upvotes) and you may bad (downvotes) opinions; to possess Tumblr, i obtained the number of „likes” and you will „reblogs” (shares) a submission acquired. Adopting the interior positions possibilities, the new 20 most widely used instances of for each meme was sampled, typically playing with 15 from reddit and you will 5 of Tumblr, since the previous is found to be a legitimate and you may respected origin. This technique are chose to better reflect this new collective advice and you may preference of the profiles since conveyed from the effective voting otherwise revealing, looking to discover the most accepted for example very user occasions of each meme members of the family. Due to the fact detailed lower than, that it decide to try is subjected to one another content and network analyses.
Posts data
The brand new hit shot was learnt playing with quantitative content study. The first phase regarding programming focused on distinguishing this quiddities into the for each and every meme family members. For every single meme including, the newest programmers detailed the main keeps you to definitely remained on the new meme or have been generally speaking common from the almost every other instances of a similar family relations (such as, a central profile, a certain terms, or an object). A good rooted, qualitative research one observed so it early stage yielded four kinds of quiddities, hence accounted for all instances we checked-out: object, step, particular character, simple character (elizabeth.g. “child” or “cat”), and you may terms. The complete corpus was then re-analyzed quantitatively, with respect to the five categories: For every single meme for example is coded because of the a few programmers for having one or higher of the four quiddity brands. At this time, an intercoder accuracy test is actually conducted (look for less than).
0 Comments